Wigglytuff and Poliwrath as Defenders
I have a Poliwrath with Bubble/Hydro Pump and a Wigglytuff with Pound/Play Rough. Both are powered to level 30.5 and have 85% plus IV. These are rated as strong defenders but I have not been able to hold gyms with them. My other top defenders do fine but these two are knocked out quickly. Are they overrated?
Answers
Exactly. It doesn't necessarily mean that a certain Pokémon is a bad defender if it can't hold a gym, because none of them can. I'm still kind of hoping that they would make attacking more difficult so there would at least be a chance to hold a gym if you put a lot of effort into it.
Wigglytuff and Poliwrath are both strong Pokémon though. Wigglytuff's biggest disadvantage in defending scenario is its low CP, it will often be the first one to get knocked out of gym. However, low CP can also be an advantage when training a friendly gym.