Which Magikarp would YOU evolve?

3 for sure. 1's IV is too low for such a huge 400 candy investment for evolution. The CP difference between 2 and 3 isn't huge so would rather higher IV, esp kuz it's perfect.

Why wouldn't you take the shot with 100%

Let us know if you get twister.

Easily #3. And hey, if you get a moveset other than "that which should not be named," at least Magikarp is a 1 km buddy, so it won't be too difficult to get the candies to power it up.

100 IV no question about it.

lmao this guy has a 100 IV karp and is asking if he should evolve that one...

Either a troll or a humblebrag post.

Send that 100IV karp to the professor or just keep it and look at it everyday without evolving it.

100% will evolve to 1874 CP - potentially useful as a prestiger/attacker if gets good moveset... If a "less ideal" moveset then collect more candy to max him out and consign him to permanent gym duty!

I'd say the question is to evolve the 100% one now or wait and hope that Gyarados gains a better fast move and then evolve.

Obviously you are going to evolve and power up the 100%. If it were me, I'd wait a bit while walking for candies to see if Gary gets some new moves. I'm sitting on 800 candies for this reason (although I do not have a 100%!).

Duh

Should change this section to Humble brag & Answer

In my opinion, individuals that are commenting that the original poster is bragging aren't seeing this question the way I am...the original poster is gauging the popular vote to see who would favor evolving a high CP vs high IV magikarp --> gyarados, a pokemon that can either work as a prestiger or be maxed out to defend gyms.

Yes, it does seem like this question is a no-brainer to some, but to others (such as my self) this is a valid question. IV's don't matter for prestigers, unlike mons that will be maxed out as defenders.

I hatched a 100% magikarp too. Only need 300 more candy to get twister.