Team Balance
I regularly visit several cities in my area on a daily basis, and one thing that really stands out to me is the fact that Valor seems to have as many, if not more, active players than the other two teams put together. This would not be such a big deal in and of itself if not for the fact that I regularly see players pass up a number of friendly gyms that are nowhere near level 10 (and it is not uncommon to see an obvious bubblestrat defender on a level 5-6 gym that is passed up,) just to take down the one gym in a mile radius that is not already red. Most gyms will stay up for a matter of hours if they are not red, while several red gyms end up staying red for days or weeks at a time.
I am not sure what Niantic can do to address this, but I was wondering if anyone has noticed a similar trend in their area, and what ideas were out there as possible solutions to this.
Answers
Blue Dominates Here.
Seems Yellow is the least likely team to dominate.
An idea I posted weeks ago here to fix this was
1) Allow Team Changes on say a 3 Month Timer
2) Rank Teams when you collect based on # of Gyms each team holds in a Region (dont tell player region boundries)
3) Give the 2nd place team 50% More Dust (not coins)
4) Give the 3rd place team 100% More Dust on Collect
If you gave greater rewards to the teams behind. You would empower them + you would tempt some hardcore players to switch teams for extra rewards
Both would self-regulate
An idea I posted weeks ago here to fix this was
1) Allow Team Changes on say a 3 Month Timer
[...]
Both would self-regulate
I am not sure, whether it would really self regulate. Maybe the last yellow players would switch to blue, just to get into the more permanent gyms.
Therefore i would suggest, that it should be impossible to change to the most popular team in the area (Niantic knows the places where a player plays most and knows, how many gyms in that area were held by each color for the last 30 days)
They would not need to share details, just not allow to change to the leading team.
This would be a second, external regulating mechanism, that would work, when self-regulation fails.
People attack rival gyms because prestiging, for some people is harder than attacking a rival team since to get 1000 prestige (what you get for attacking a rival gym), you HAVE to use half CP mons which takes longer, harder, more potions/revives, etc....
This is why they drive out just to tear down a rival gym since it's easier and more time efficient (unless the rival gym is also level 10) to get their 10 coins...
This is probably the only skill in the game and separates the better players than weaker players.
I prestige level 7+ gyms all the time if I can put something down since it's not too slow for me and other than erroring out like 2 or 3 times, it's not too bad...The crashes suck though since it's like at least 2 or 3 crashes if I try to get 8k which is really annoying.
My area is all yellow spoofer, I have to go north to the next city to find the blue spoofer dominant area and south to find the red spoofer dominant area.
I wish they assigned random teams once a month. Every month on the first all gyms are brought to 0. Any player that enters a gym will be randomly be assigned to a team for the next 30 days or after every other migration. I think this would mix up the gym meta without needing a whole new "system" being created.
The whole switching teams thing just seems wrong to me and makes things worst for most players (familes/friends, etc...) than solve any real issue...
I hear some Instinct people group up and are able to take any area due to sheer hard core playing/dedication and most of the blue/red just don't need to coordinate as much due to sheer numbers.
Ultimately, the main problem is dominant areas and lack of rewards for attacking lvl 10 gyms, but there are more important things to fix I believe than letting people rechoose teams.
Being Instinct gets frustrating sometimes where I live.
Overall I don't mind being the underdog but I see blue gyms stacked with Snorlax and high-CP Rhydon and Gyarados that stick around for a day or two (that's a long time around here) and the second a yellow gym gets any momentum going, people are putting 1200CP Jynx and Jolteon in it and it disappears within an hour or two. I'm not talking new players, these are level 25-30 players. I'm all in favour of variety of mons in a gym but surely we can do better than that :-) It does make me want to switch teams sometimes but it also kinda makes it more rewarding in a way when we do get a gym going.
There's one Instinct guy with a few absolute mega-mons who I seem to end up co-defending gyms with a lot. GenCario if you're on here, I salute you sir!
Edit to add - the main road out of the city to where I work is absolutely dominated by Instinct - the only such area I have ever seen. There are often 3 or 4 yellow gyms stacked high. It's refreshing to see :-)