GamePress

Stamina or defense

Hi, i've been wondering recently which of the too stats is more important when it comes to fighting. I had understood that defense and attack were mostly used for "assaulting" gyms and stamina for "defending", is that true?
In any case will a pokemon of the same species with (for example) 100 defense and 50 stamina resist the same amount of DPS than other with 50 defense and 100 stamina?

Thank you

Asked by Naen8 years 7 months ago

Hi, i've been wondering recently which of the too stats is more important when it comes to fighting. I had understood that defense and attack were mostly used for "assaulting" gyms and stamina for "defending", is that true?
In any case will a pokemon of the same species with (for example) 100 defense and 50 stamina resist the same amount of DPS than other with 50 defense and 100 stamina?

Thank you

Asked by Naen8 years 7 months ago

Hi, i've been wondering recently which of the too stats is more important when it comes to fighting. I had understood that defense and attack were mostly used for "assaulting" gyms and stamina for "defending", is that true?
In any case will a pokemon of the same species with (for example) 100 defense and 50 stamina resist the same amount of DPS than other with 50 defense and 100 stamina?

Thank you

Asked by Naen8 years 7 months ago

Hi, i've been wondering recently which of the too stats is more important when it comes to fighting. I had understood that defense and attack were mostly used for "assaulting" gyms and stamina for "defending", is that true?
In any case will a pokemon of the same species with (for example) 100 defense and 50 stamina resist the same amount of DPS than other with 50 defense and 100 stamina?

Thank you

Asked by Naen8 years 7 months ago

Hi, i've been wondering recently which of the too stats is more important when it comes to fighting. I had understood that defense and attack were mostly used for "assaulting" gyms and stamina for "defending", is that true?
In any case will a pokemon of the same species with (for example) 100 defense and 50 stamina resist the same amount of DPS than other with 50 defense and 100 stamina?

Thank you

Asked by Naen8 years 7 months ago

Hi, i've been wondering recently which of the too stats is more important when it comes to fighting. I had understood that defense and attack were mostly used for "assaulting" gyms and stamina for "defending", is that true?
In any case will a pokemon of the same species with (for example) 100 defense and 50 stamina resist the same amount of DPS than other with 50 defense and 100 stamina?

Thank you

Asked by Naen8 years 7 months ago

Hi, i've been wondering recently which of the too stats is more important when it comes to fighting. I had understood that defense and attack were mostly used for "assaulting" gyms and stamina for "defending", is that true?
In any case will a pokemon of the same species with (for example) 100 defense and 50 stamina resist the same amount of DPS than other with 50 defense and 100 stamina?

Thank you

Asked by Naen8 years 7 months ago

Hi, i've been wondering recently which of the too stats is more important when it comes to fighting. I had understood that defense and attack were mostly used for "assaulting" gyms and stamina for "defending", is that true?
In any case will a pokemon of the same species with (for example) 100 defense and 50 stamina resist the same amount of DPS than other with 50 defense and 100 stamina?

Thank you

Asked by Naen8 years 7 months ago

Hi, i've been wondering recently which of the too stats is more important when it comes to fighting. I had understood that defense and attack were mostly used for "assaulting" gyms and stamina for "defending", is that true?
In any case will a pokemon of the same species with (for example) 100 defense and 50 stamina resist the same amount of DPS than other with 50 defense and 100 stamina?

Thank you

Asked by Naen8 years 7 months ago

Hi, i've been wondering recently which of the too stats is more important when it comes to fighting. I had understood that defense and attack were mostly used for "assaulting" gyms and stamina for "defending", is that true?
In any case will a pokemon of the same species with (for example) 100 defense and 50 stamina resist the same amount of DPS than other with 50 defense and 100 stamina?

Thank you

Asked by Naen8 years 7 months ago

Hi, i've been wondering recently which of the too stats is more important when it comes to fighting. I had understood that defense and attack were mostly used for "assaulting" gyms and stamina for "defending", is that true?
In any case will a pokemon of the same species with (for example) 100 defense and 50 stamina resist the same amount of DPS than other with 50 defense and 100 stamina?

Thank you

Asked by Naen8 years 7 months ago

Hi, i've been wondering recently which of the too stats is more important when it comes to fighting. I had understood that defense and attack were mostly used for "assaulting" gyms and stamina for "defending", is that true?
In any case will a pokemon of the same species with (for example) 100 defense and 50 stamina resist the same amount of DPS than other with 50 defense and 100 stamina?

Thank you

Asked by Naen8 years 7 months ago

Hi, i've been wondering recently which of the too stats is more important when it comes to fighting. I had understood that defense and attack were mostly used for "assaulting" gyms and stamina for "defending", is that true?
In any case will a pokemon of the same species with (for example) 100 defense and 50 stamina resist the same amount of DPS than other with 50 defense and 100 stamina?

Thank you

Asked by Naen8 years 7 months ago

Hi, i've been wondering recently which of the too stats is more important when it comes to fighting. I had understood that defense and attack were mostly used for "assaulting" gyms and stamina for "defending", is that true?
In any case will a pokemon of the same species with (for example) 100 defense and 50 stamina resist the same amount of DPS than other with 50 defense and 100 stamina?

Thank you

Asked by Naen8 years 7 months ago

Hi, i've been wondering recently which of the too stats is more important when it comes to fighting. I had understood that defense and attack were mostly used for "assaulting" gyms and stamina for "defending", is that true?
In any case will a pokemon of the same species with (for example) 100 defense and 50 stamina resist the same amount of DPS than other with 50 defense and 100 stamina?

Thank you

Asked by Naen8 years 7 months ago

Hi, i've been wondering recently which of the too stats is more important when it comes to fighting. I had understood that defense and attack were mostly used for "assaulting" gyms and stamina for "defending", is that true?
In any case will a pokemon of the same species with (for example) 100 defense and 50 stamina resist the same amount of DPS than other with 50 defense and 100 stamina?

Thank you

Asked by Naen8 years 7 months ago

Hi, i've been wondering recently which of the too stats is more important when it comes to fighting. I had understood that defense and attack were mostly used for "assaulting" gyms and stamina for "defending", is that true?
In any case will a pokemon of the same species with (for example) 100 defense and 50 stamina resist the same amount of DPS than other with 50 defense and 100 stamina?

Thank you

Asked by Naen8 years 7 months ago

Hi, i've been wondering recently which of the too stats is more important when it comes to fighting. I had understood that defense and attack were mostly used for "assaulting" gyms and stamina for "defending", is that true?
In any case will a pokemon of the same species with (for example) 100 defense and 50 stamina resist the same amount of DPS than other with 50 defense and 100 stamina?

Thank you

Asked by Naen8 years 7 months ago
Report

Answers

stamina relates to HP, defence mitigates damage related to the opponents attack, AFAIK. Therefore HP seems more valuable to me. I'm sorry I'm not 100% certain but I would think for the aforementioned reasons that stamina would be preferable to defence.

Up
0
Down

by POkeGoing 8 years 8 months ago

Defense and Stamina are not interchangeable like in the example you demonstrated. they do not work as simple as that.

reason being is that Stamina as a stat is calculated differently than the other stats.

I would say both are important, try comparing defense against attack stat because i know those two stats are in the damage calculation.

check out the damage calc at the end of the page, it could be useful. base damage is the exact number it will take from the opponent pokemon

http://pokemongo.gamepress.gg/combat

Up
0
Down

Go with STAMINA. You can dodge in battles which means that you can mitigate A TON of damage ( you don't need to dodge everything perfectly... you'll surely be taking some chip-damage, but having a higher HP pool will help more than higher defence which would still lead to almost the same chip-damage... ). Ideally, you'd want both to be good, but until then, STAMINA gives you more room for error and it keeps you longer in fights ( when combined with dodging, it is absolutely better than having DEF in a gym battle ).

Up
0
Down

I had 2 10K eggs that turned out to be Onix. My buddy keeps saying "but he has real high defense." I'll try one in a battle and see how bad it gets murdered and let you know...

Up
0
Down