Gyarados giving 100 stardust 3 candies?

If I ever caught a wild Gyarados, I wouldn't complain about getting shorted 200 dust and 3 Magikarp candies.

The same is about Magmar - it is 3 candies

Might be it just showed wrong on one of catch screens. I offer this possibility because I've noticed a Pinap berry glitch, where the first screen after catching shows 3 candies then rolls up to 5 showing Pinap berry being applied. But click the check mark to get to next screen and it temporarily shows correct in upper right that you got 6 berries. .....Or maybe I'm not understanding the whole Pinap thing :)

But will keep an eye on what you mention next time I see any evolved wild mon. (Albeit it ain't gonna be a Gyarados for me...)

Yeah this happened to me to, and he also had a crappy IV.