Idle "What if" Level 1 Perfect Pokemon

I have a 100% Ursaring, caught as Teddi that was lvl2 - he will go to lvl30

Only if they rolled perfect movesets. No exceptions. Rhydon isn't in the best place rn compared to others so I'd probably evolve and keep it as a trophy. Eevee is too common

Shiny Magikarp because why the heck not.

Snorlax, all the Snorlaxs that I have caught are below 50%.

It is hard to know if they are perfect at L1. I maxed about a 96 L6 dratini that I hatched last year. She's my oldest mon.

I would probably give them all an evo. I would only power up the ones with perfect movesets though. Even then in some cases I would probably put it off for bit while I use the candies more effectively elsewhere.

I've maxed a level 2 95% Chansey -> Blissey...

Before evolving/powering up, it could've been 98% so I went for it anyways. It's my 3rd oldest Pokemon...

From your list, I'd also max a shiny perfect Gyarados for sure due to rather having 1 shiny high CP one vs. multiples...

Would also do Eevee since candies are easy.

I'd keep them as part of the collection aspect of the game. I consider that an investment since they'd be taking up valuable space in my box.

The Snorlax would be tempting to power up since all mine are mostly average. Definitely would require good moves du jour.

It would be cool to have a whole army of 100% level 1 elite mons. Just because.

I would say this is my order

1.(Chansey)

2.(Dragonite)

3.(Larvitar)

here are my reasons, blissey is the best defender by far. Number two Dragonite is the best generalist in this current no lapras meta. Number 3 Tyranitar is still great for the current meta and will be even better when lengedaries come out and they start popping up in gyms.

That depends on the availability of each Pokemon's candy. I'd definitely evolve the Eevee and the shiny Karp. And probably the Dratini and Rhyhorn too. As for leveling up, only those with the best moveset and if I have enough stardust to spare (definitely not a priority).

Eevee is the most obvious one, but no one is picking it.

It only costs 25 candies to find out if you have a Ember/Heat Wave Flareon or a AT Vaporeon.

Personally I wouldn't evolve any other than the eevee.

Shinny Gyarados only with DT/any

I've been trying to decide that about my 100% Eevee for quite a while. He was only level 5, and turned into a Jolteon with Thunder months ago (when Thunder Shock was the only possibility for his quick attack). I kept thinking I would power him up some time, but somehow I've just left him that way so far.

For those other ones, I'd probably say no to most of them just because it's too hard to get all that extra candy. I've never gotten even 1 Larvitar candy before, so it would take forever to max one of those if I actually got one. Magikarp, though, sure, I'd go ahead and do that, since I already have 753 candy for them anyway that I've just been saving up waiting for a good candidate to evolve. And then Chansey is the other one I'd say yes, since it's only 50 to evolve, and I've been wanting to get my first Blissey.

none, ever. i don't even appraise anything above lv.20/hatched - i could have multched several perfect pokes by now but i focus on levelling defenders, then prestigers (1200cp and 1500cp teams of stuff that beats the big 7) then finally attackers. have neither time nor resources to level anything unhatched.